Is adoption the answer? it is not for a lot children, government figures leaked show that a third of children adopted out of care fail and the child is returned right back into the system. This is why children under 5 are more adoptable because they do not remember their birth family and so the new adoptive parents have a home free run with a child claiming as being theirs, which of course is not the case only by way of a family court.. isnt that emotional abuse (or legal abuse) in itself? at what point is that child going to find out? Are the adopters going to hide the big secret until the child is 18 then drop the bombshell?? how will it affect the child or indeed when they become adult? identitycrisis comes to mind..
Are children’s services really doing a ‘service’ to the child in cases such as this ?(the links might not be for the faint hearted)..http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-480151/Gay-couple-left-free-abuse-boys–social-workers-feared-branded-homophobic.html and http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1158497/Foster-parents-sue-social-workers-placed-teenager-home–leaving-free-rape-son.html , http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/article-23389711-sadistic-foster-mothers-19-year-reign-of-terror.do, http://www.peterboroughtoday.co.uk/news/environment/pervert_foster_carer_abused_child_1_84286, http://menmedia.co.uk/manchestereveningnews/news/s/1305600_foster_carer_caught_on_film_attacking_toddler,
It seems the Americans are also having problems with the system there too , a high profile murder of Logan Marr involving an ex social worker http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/fostercare/marr/marrwma_hi.html
I myself can identify with this one in that my concerns about my sons behaviour whilst in care fell on dear ears and i was made out to be a nurotic mother who wanted my son out of foster care and would say or do anything to achieve that, well they were right about that to a degree. Never would a caring protective parent want to make up concerns about their child in care. Most caring responsible parents are more intune with their children more than anyone else and know instinctively when there is something wrong. The most horrifying of all of it is that childrens services cover up their mistakes/embarrassment and sometimes convince police reports of a child suffering in care are unfounded. This is because if their investigations or court prove it to be true then they have to admit they were wrong and also leads to big pay outs.
My son in 2010 was diagnosed as having an attachment disorder, where by he had strong attachment to me (always has but certain social workers didnt seem to be bothered) and does not like to be away from me for too long, he also has ADHD diagnosed (social services missed that one putting his hyperactivity and frustrations down to DV as they did with his strong attachment to me). The problems my son had in foster care he certainly did not have when he was with me or indeed even when his father was with us.Most of the problems that occurred in foster care disappeared the minute i was reunited with him so knowing all this now how could it have possibly been a good thing to put my son into care?? can you imagine the outcome of the adoption?? I dread to think if i had not done what i did that my son would have ended up in a childrens home after a failed adoption, he would not have got the help with his ADHD or attachment disorder (i dont think there is a cure for that) like he has had and continues to have. The fear is he would probably have been medicated upto the eyeballs to make him more manageable and ended up a total flop in life with major emotional problems and addictions as an adult possibly adding to the prison population.
http://www.afro.com/sections/news/Washington/story.htm?storyid=3779 and http://www.weau.com/home/headlines/Adoption_advocates_charged_with_child_abuse_112914229.html , http://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local-beat/Renee-Bowman-To-Be-Sentenced-88810207.html ,http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MqSum5Qlx1w, 15 cases of U.S adoptions of russian children murdered by adoptive parents http://adoption.about.com/od/adoptionrights/p/russiancases.htm
UK Research in 1999 (i should think the figure is alot higher now more children go into care) shows that a child is 6/7 more likely to be abused in state care than the family home,whilst 6% of those abused in care were abused in children’s homes/residential care. That leaves a high figure for abuse in foster care, the reasons for this i willgo into in another blog . The message to the government is (do the maths) provide a service which is meant to ‘help families’ not a service of child collection for adoption on flimsy evidence if’s and but’s. Put your resources into seeking out families who need that help instead of making families feel like they are under serveillance, due to the mass media coverage and internet cases of child abuse within birth families and the care system it is clear that children are best left in the home of families unless there is clear and re-occuring evidence of physical, sexual or severe neglect and put those emotional harm cases forward for home help. Funding should go heavily into ’training’ parents to be good parents isnt that what social services were originally designed to do? In Ireland they would not attempt to take a child for emotional harm unless their was psychiatric medical evidence to prove this over a period of time. As one social worker said ‘why would we want to remove a child from its parents if we did not know for CERTAIN that child was suffering and would suffer at home more than they would incare’. EXACTLY listen to the words of the Irish social worker!
Due to the current governments cuts to get rid of the debt labour left behind millions of county councils are having to re-shuffle the work force and lets hope they prioritise their cases more and protect those children who need protecting. Government also needs to set down clear rules regarding weighing up the harm children maybe suffering at home to whatthey might suffer in care or go onto suffer when adopted..i will include emotional harm in that why not.
As a final word I must say that i have no argument against adoption whenbirth parents agree or if i a child has been abandoned for say 2 years as is the current law in Ireland and other EU countries. I am sure that some adoptions are a great success when things are done correctly and those caring adoptors do a great job with children who need a family.










